The Judges' Decision Is Final

Every image gets judged by somebody. It helps to know who, and to tell the people making it

I've moved to Plymouth, and last night I went along to a local camera club. It meets every Thursday, and I thought it would be a gentle way of integrating myself into society.

It turned out to be competition night. An inter-club contest, with each club's photographs put up one at a time, a panel of judges scoring every one, and a shield for the club with the most points. I'd expected a quiet evening and walked into a local derby!

Smeaton's Tower on The Hoe in Plymouth

Marked Down

The images were wide-ranging, in the best sense. Every style and every subject you can think of.

So I did what I suspect most people in the room were doing - tried to work out what the judges liked. I couldn't. Something I thought was excellent got a low mark. Something I'd have passed over scored well. Not every time, but often enough that I gave up looking for a pattern.

It wasn't random, of course. The judges presumably had their criteria, and their own preferences within them. I just couldn't work out what either was.

Photography is subjective. So is music, so is architecture, and so, a little awkwardly, is architectural visualisation, which is what I do for a living. Interesting…

You Know Your Judges

There's one big difference between my evening at a camera club and your next development.

I spent the night guessing at the judges. Most of the time, our clients don't have to.

A planning image might be examined by officers assessing the proposal, members weighing its impact and neighbours working out what it means for their own homes. A marketing image might go in front of an occupier, the agent advising them or an investment committee.

They may all be looking at the same scheme.

They aren't asking the same questions.

That's the part that gets overlooked. "Occupiers" isn't an audience. An operations director choosing between three units, who mainly wants to know whether the yard works, is an audience. "The public" isn't one either. Forty households on the eastern boundary who want to know what they'll see from upstairs is.

The more precisely the audience is described, the easier every decision becomes to justify. Viewpoint, light, season, how many people and what they're doing are still creative choices, but there's now something more useful than personal taste to measure them against.

It isn't the same as pleasing them, either. Sometimes the most useful image is the one that makes an awkward consequence impossible to misunderstand.

Tell Us Who They Are

But it only helps if it reaches the people actually making the image/film.

You usually know your audience far better than we do. (That's "we" as in the whole visualisation industry, not just Blink.) You've sat in the meetings, read the objections and met the occupier. We haven't. A brief that says "four CGIs of Unit 2" leaves us guessing at the judges, which puts us straight back in the camera club.

So tell your visualisation team as much as you can, as early as you can. Who will look at this? What do they need to understand by the end? What will they check first, and what would make them distrust it? It rarely arrives fully formed, and a good studio should be asking for it anyway. The answers at planning are different from the answers at marketing, even for the same building.

The Panel in the Room

There's a second panel, and it's closer to home: the client team itself. Five people reviewing a draft are five judges. The architect is checking the detail. The agent is thinking about impact. The developer has a view on how the scheme should come across. Somebody simply doesn't like the sky.

None of them is wrong. But none of them is the audience either. An image can go through three rounds of comments, satisfy everybody on the project team, and still not answer the one thing the person it was made for wanted to know. A compromise that pleases the room isn't necessarily an improvement.

Before anybody reviews a draft, agree in one sentence what the image is supposed to help somebody understand, and write it down. Then hold every comment up against it. "I don't like the sky" is one person's taste. "Will this help the neighbours understand what they'll see?" is something a team can actually argue about. It doesn't remove the disagreement. It gives it somewhere to go.

None of that means commissioning anything extra. If anything, it shortens the rounds of comments you were going to have anyway.

None of this makes an image objective, and I wouldn't claim otherwise. You can know an audience well and still misjudge them. But there's a real difference between an image tuned to somebody and an image hoping for the best.

As for the camera club, I never did work out what the judges were after. The clubs that win shields presumably have.

Until next week.

Rich

PS: If anybody from a Plymouth camera club is reading this, I'd welcome a briefing on the judges before I enter anything (not cheating of course… ;-)